Shalom Hartman Institute

Main Jewish Responses to Trauma

1. Supplication (Prayer and Fasting)

• Prayer is a universal Jewish response during crisis; even less religious individuals often turn to prayer in traumatic times.
• Fasting is presented as a traditional, embodied plea for divine intervention, reflecting human vulnerability. Rabbinic and Talmudic examples include Rabbi Tzadok’s 40-year fast before the fall of Jerusalem.
• The core idea is to acknowledge human limitations and seek strength or mercy beyond the self.

2. Mutual Support

• Community care is central: supporting one another through suffering, even when broader solutions aren’t available.
• Talmudic teachings emphasize that one cannot lift oneself out of suffering alone—mutual aid benefits both giver and receiver.
• Contemporary examples (e.g., bereaved families supporting each other) reinforce this theme of interdependence.

3. Introspection

• Trauma prompts self-examination, from metaphysical (“God is angry at us”) to political (failures of leadership or communal cohesion).
• Introspection is double-edged: it can promote growth or entrench preexisting narratives.
• Diaspora perspectives are explored, especially how American Jews respond to Israeli crises or historical trauma like the Holocaust.
• Alienation, assimilation, or rejection of Jewish identity are also recognized as trauma responses.

4. Hope

• Hope is deeply rooted in Jewish tradition and sustained through several forms:
  
  • Reframing current enemies through historical archetypes (e.g., modern Hamans).
  • Emphasizing continuity: as long as Jews exist, hope endures.
  • Theological resilience: belief that even if God is hidden or angry, God still suffers with the people.
  • National symbols like “Hatikvah” (The Hope) reflect this ethos.

5. Vision for the Future

• Even in dark times, Jewish tradition often calls for forward-looking imagination (e.g., Jeremiah’s instruction to build lives in Babylonian exile).
• Personal narratives, such as a child growing up in wartime, illustrate how life and growth persist despite chaos.
• The imperative to rebuild, teach, and nurture life remains central.

Contemporary Challenges and Reflections

Fundamentalism and Community Divisions

• Discussion of Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) fundamentalism, including:
  
  • Reliance solely on prayer
  • Refusal to serve in the military
  • Separation from broader society
• These patterns are linked to historic traumas and responses to modernity, but also critiqued for their social consequences.
• Fundamentalism is acknowledged across religious and political spectrums—often providing psychological safety but limiting openness and dialogue.

Diaspora-Israel Relations and Identity Crisis

• Tensions have intensified between American and Israeli Jews post-October 7, particularly around responsibility, connection, and activism.
• Distancing from Jewish identity—or even embracing anti-Zionist stances—is discussed as a trauma response.
• The group considers whether alienation or betrayal should be understood as an additional trauma response category.

The Limits and Risks of Introspection

• Introspection can sometimes reinforce existing worldviews rather than lead to meaningful change.
• The group emphasizes the need for honest, context-aware reflection—without rushing to tidy explanations or blame.

Conclusion

• Jewish responses to trauma are multifaceted, historically grounded, and continually evolving.
• The five core responses—supplication, mutual support, introspection, hope, and vision—often coexist and reinforce one another.
• The conversation highlighted the diversity and complexity of Jewish experience, the risks of fundamentalism, and the importance of solidarity and self-awareness in times of crisis.

Donate to Shalom Hartman

Bio

Dr. Elana Stein Hain is the Rosh Beit Midrash and a senior research fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute of North America, where she serves as lead faculty and consults on the content of lay and professional programs.

A widely well-regarded thinker and teacher, Elana is passionate about bringing rabbinic thought into conversation with contemporary life. To this end, she hosts TEXTing, a bi-weekly podcast that considers issues relevant to Jewish life through the lens of classical and modern Torah texts; she also teaches Talmud from the Balcony, an occasional learning seminar exposing the big ideas, questions, and issues motivating rabbinic discussions. Elana is the author of Circumventing the Law: Rabbinic Perspectives on Legal Loopholes and Integrity, which uses loopholes as a lens for understanding rabbinic views on law and ethics.

She earned her doctorate in Religion at Columbia University and is an alumna of the Yeshiva University Graduate Program in Advanced Talmudic Studies (GPATS), as well as the Consortium in Jewish Studies and Legal Theory Graduate Fellowship at Cardozo School of Law. She also served for eight years as a clergy member on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, at both Lincoln Square Synagogue and the Jewish Center, has taught at the Wagner School at NYU, and sits on the board of Sefaria.